JAP论文接收,分享我投稿经历-酸甜苦辣.docVIP

JAP论文接收,分享我投稿经历-酸甜苦辣 今天收到邮件，我的一篇Journal of Applied Physics 论文已被接收，心情当时还是有点激动。虽然这个杂志的影响因子不是很高，大概2.2左右吧，这也不是我的第一篇SCI论文，但回想这一年发文章的坎坎坷坷，以及亲身经历的四川大地震，心里还是有很多的感触。 这篇论文是我在2008年二月份完成的最初稿，于二月九号投到Physics Letters A上，在经历了Technical check，with editor，under review后，于三月二十号收到编辑的决定信，当时就傻了－拒稿！受打击了。下面是编辑的信以及审稿意见，我想把它贴出来和虫友们分享，一方面我认为，通过看审稿人的意见，可以帮助大家更好地写作，提高自己的科研水平与能力，另一方面也是答谢小木虫上很多无私的虫友们，是他们将自己的投稿经历贴在网上，和大家分享，我想我没有理由不拿出来哈！同时，也希望小木虫的虫子们能继续发扬这种精神，大家同舟共济，共同提高！好了，废话说了一大堆，不说了，下面是Physics Letters A 的审稿意见： Ms. Ref. No.: ×××××× Title: ××××× Physics Letters A Dear professor ××, Reviewers comments on your work have now been received. You will see that they are advising against publication of your work. Therefore I must reject it. For your guidance, I append the reviewers comments below. Thank you for giving us the opportunity to c*****ider your work. Yours sincerely, ×××（编辑名） Editor Physics Letters A Reviewers comments: The authors present results of the 3D electron potential of a gated quantum point contact in a AlGaAs/GaAs heterostructure. In contrast to earlier studies, it is now possible to derive the potential landshape without any adjustable parameter. The results still agree with earlier investigati***** using simpler phenomenological models. Since the used nextnano3 program is available since a couple of years, I wonder why this has not been done earlier. The authors emphasize an application of their results. Having the complete potential landshape might help, in the future, to better understand the quantized acoustoelectric current in SETSAW devices and to improve their performance. However, the authors do not show or even discuss how this can be achieved. Therefore I believe that in the present form the paper is not suitable for publication. The authors should c*****ider the following suggesti*****, questi*****, and remarks. 1) Page 1, first paragraph ... due to the negatively applied gate voltage .... It is the SAW that drives the electr***** through the contact, not the gate voltage