论我国刑法中的期待可能性_以许霆案为分析视角_高婉淇.pdfVIP

本文摘自开封教育学院学报 论我国刑法中的期待可能性：以许霆案为分析视角 高婉淇，童伟华 （海南大学 法学院，海南 海口570228） 【摘 要】许霆案虽然已经过去，但作为一个标志性的案件依然值得深入探讨。不管从具体案情还是从两次判决 的巨大差异来看，该案不可避免地成为公众关注的焦点。许霆案映射出了法理与情理的冲突。许霆案最终减为5 年 有期徒刑的重审结果是源于对期待可能性理论精神内核的运用。期待可能性理论所具有的一些合理的精神内核值 得我国借鉴，它能使刑法更加人性化而得以实现更好的社会效果，我国刑法有很多因素能与期待可能性理论相契合。 【关键词】期待可能性；意志自由；人性弱点；谦抑性 ( ) 【中图分类号】D914 【文献标识码】A 【文章编号】1673 ―2391 2016 03 ―0106 ―07 Discussion on the Anticipated Possibility of Chinese Criminal Law from Xu Ting Case Gao Wanqi, Tong Weihua （Hainan University, Haikou 570228, China） Abstract: The Xu Ting case has been in the past, but as a trademark case, it is still worthy of further discussion.Whether it is from specific details or from wide differences between two judgments, this case inevitably becomes the focus of public attention and reflects the conflict between law and reason. The result of eventually reducing to five years imprisonment come from the application of the theory of anticipated possibility. Some reasonable spiritual kernel of the anticipated possibility theory are worth learning, which make the criminal law more humane and social effects better. Many factors of the criminal law in China also interact with this theory. Key words: Anticipated Possibility; Will Freedom; Weakness of Humanity; Modest and Restrained Principle 期待可能性理论源于德国的“癖马案”，该案过 取款1 万余元，事后，两人携款潜逃。2007 年，广州 后，期待可能性理论为学界所重视并不断发展和完 市中级人民法院一审认定许霆犯了盗窃罪，并属于 善，可以说在刑法中有着较为重要的理论研究价值。 盗窃金融机构，情节严重，判处无期徒刑。许霆不服， 期待可能性理论在国外有着较深的理论渊源，我国 提出上诉，2008 年广东省高院将该案发回重审。而