国际期刊审稿流程及要点.pdfVIP

国际期刊审稿流程与要点 国际期刊审稿流程与要点 清华大学自动化系 张 贤 达 电话 zxd-dau@tsinghua.edu.cn 目 录 国际期刊审稿流程 审稿要点 论文写作要点 论文修改要点 如何改进英文表述 国际期刊审稿流程 国际期刊审稿流程 作者投稿（以电子投稿为例） Editor in Chief 或其办公室选择Associate Editor Associate Editor选择Reviewers Reviewers审稿 Associate Editor作决定 RQ：Reject (Rewrite Again After Major Changes) AQ ：Publish in Minor, Required Change R：Reject (Paper Is Not Of Sufficient Quality Or Novelty To Be Published In This Transactions) 国际期刊审稿流程（续） 国际期刊审稿流程（续） 作者投送修改稿 Associate Editor组织第2次审稿 Reviewers审查作者对审稿意见的回答意见 Reviewers审查修改稿 Associate Editor作决定 发表 小修改后发表 Reject 审稿要点 I. REVIEW Please expand and give details in Section III. A. Suitability of topic 1. Is the topic appropriate for publication in these transactions? ( ) Yes ( ) Perhaps ( ) No 2. Is the topic important to colleagues working in the field? ( ) Yes ( ) Moderately So ( ) No (explain: ) 审稿要点（续） 审稿要点（续） B. Content 1. Is the paper technically sound? ( ) Yes ( ) No (why not? )/P 2. Is the coverage of the topic sufficiently comprehensive and balanced? ( ) Yes ( ) Important information is missing or superficially treated. ( ) Treatment somewhat unbalanced, but not seriously so. ( ) Certain parts significantly overstresses. 审稿要点（续） 审稿要点（续） 3. How would you describe the technical depth of the paper? ( ) Superficial ( ) Suitable for the non-specialist ( ) Appropriate for the Generally Knowledgeable Individual Working in the Field or a Related Field ( ) Suitable only for an Expert 4. How would you rate the technical novelty of the paper? ( ) Novel ( ) Somewhat Novel ( ) Not Novel 审稿要点（续） 审稿要点（续） C. Presentation